Alpaca Articles : Herd Protectors
Coyote predation on sheep
Guard llama with sheep gathered at his side
Make no mistake about it: coyotes kill sheep. In fact, predation is a leading cause of sheep mortality and represents a serious problem for the sheep industry. Sheep losses due to all types of predation in the United States were more than $83 million in 1987, up from $72 million in 1986 and $69 million in 1985. The losses in 1987 represent 5 percent of the total sheep population in the United States. Lambs are particularly vulnerable. Lamb losses from predation average 9 percent and vary from 3 percent to 14 percent of the lambs. Sheep are found in every state of the union, and losses due to predation vary. In Iowa, the state with the largest number of sheep operations, intensive field studies revealed that 41 percent of all sheep losses were from canid predators (coyotes and dogs), 46 percent from non-predator causes (disease, starvation, etc.), and 13 percent from unknown causes. Retired U.S. Department of Agriculture sheep scientist, Clair Terrill, calculated economic losses due to predation. In Texas, the state with the largest number of sheep, predation was responsible for 14 percent to 69 percent of all sheep losses. Texas also led the nation in economic loss due to predation on sheep ($12 million), followed by California ($9 million), Wyoming ($7 million), Iowa ($6 million), Utah ($6 million), and Colorado ($5 million).
For an industry operating on a low profit margin, losses due to predation have resulted not only in reduced revenue for the producer, but also in higher prices paid by the consumer for meat and wool products. Predation is a real problem with a major impact on the sheep industry. It is a critical issue with both economic and ethical implications to wildlife management, the livestock industry, and the general public.
Reducing coyote predation Integrated predation management
Over the last 150 years, many methods for reducing predation of sheep have been tried. In general, methods can be divided into a) preventive methods and b) control. Preventive methods are implemented prior to predation problems and are generally non-lethal to the predators. These include the use of fencing, guard animals, frightening devices, and sheep husbandry techniques, such as night penning and shed lambing.
Control methods usually are put into place after damage has occurred and are targeted at specific animals, usually being lethal to the predator. These methods include shooting, poisons, trapping and snaring, and fumigants. Local and state regulations regarding these regulations vary. The best flock protection is provided by an integrated management program that includes both preventive and selected control methods. No single method is 100 percent effective by itself. An integrated approach is the most ecologically and economically sound, yielding the best long-term protection.
Recently, the search for a simpler, non-lethal technique to reduce coyote predation has led to the experimental and field use of guard animals. A guard animal is any animal that, when placed with a flock, represents a threat to predators. The ideal guard animal should protect sheep against predation, while requiring minimal training, care, and maintenance. It should stay with and not disrupt or harm the flock, and be cost effective. A variety of guard animals currently in use includes dogs, donkeys (burros), and llamas. Of these, guard dogs are by far the most common.
During the past decade and a half with the birth and growth of the llama industry in North America, llamas were occasionally pastured with sheep. To the surprise of owners, they noticed fewer sheep were being lost to coyotes. Producers began experimenting with llamas as guard animals. Today, their use in North America is on the increase.
What is a llama?
Llamas are members of the South American camel family, where four camelids are found: the domesticated llama and alpaca, and the wild guanaco and vicuña. Surprisingly, llamas and their camel relatives were originally native to the grasslands and deserts of North America, but suddenly disappeared from here 10,000 to 15,000 years ago, about the time of the last glacial advance.
Today, llamas are used in the Andean Mountains as beasts of burden for carrying produce and trade goods. Alpacas come in a variety of natural colors, and their fine wool is made into soft sweaters and blankets. Guanacos have brown bodies and blackish faces and are found primarily on the Patagonia of southern Argentina, while the smaller vicuña dwells in the high altiplano grasslands of the Central Andes.
Because domesticated llamas originated from guanacos, the two have much in common. Llamas, guanacos, alpacas, and their hybrids are used as guard animals for sheep, but all are referred to in a generic sense as guard llamas.
Do guard llamas really work?
What is the llama’s potential as a non-lethal alternative for reducing sheep losses to the 105,000 sheep producers of North America? While anecdotal articles and stories on guard llamas have been encouraging, there has been an absence of systematic studies on guard llamas to accurately assess their effectiveness. Many unknowns exist, including:
Research on guard llamas at Iowa State University was initiated in 1990 to address the above questions. Telephone interviews were conducted with 145 sheep ranchers across the country using guard llamas. Questions dealt with specific sheep management practices and characteristics of guard llamas. In addition, researchers traveled to six midwestern and western states in the summer of 1991 for on-site visits to 29 sheep ranches using guard llamas. This bulletin summarises that investigation and applies other studies conducted through Iowa State University.
Current use of guard llamas
There are a great variety of settings where guard llamas are run with sheep: from the stubble wheat fields of the central plains, to the mountain meadows and open rangelands of the west. Guard llamas are found in many states, with the majority in the intermountain west (Montana, Wyoming, and Colorado) and far west (California and Oregon).
The average producer interviewed has raised sheep for 17 years and purchased a llama 3 years earlier from a llama breeder. The average producer had a similar breakdown of predator problems to the national study, with coyotes reported as the biggest problem. Nearly 70 percent of guard llamas are gelded males costing between $300 to $800; intact males are about $100 cheaper. A few ranchers own as many as six llamas but most have only one. One guard llama may be kept with as few as four sheep or as many as 2,100. Average flock size of those ranchers interviewed is 250 to 300 sheep maintained in a pasture of 250 to 300 acres. Since this is a fairly new management technique, producers have used guard llamas an average of 3 years, but some for as long as 12 years. The oldest llama reported was 18 years of age. Eleven of 204 guard llamas died of a variety of causes, including old age and disease, snake bite, guard dog, and lameness.
Introducing llamas to sheep
Nearly all llamas in this study had no experience with sheep before being introduced into the flock they were to protect. In other words, they had not been trained to guard sheep. Llamas averaged 2 years of age when introduced to sheep, with the most common llama age being 6 to 11 months at introduction. The circumstances surrounding guard llama introduction to sheep vary greatly: small to large flocks, lambs to adults, indoors to outdoors, and small to large pastures. However, most are introduced to the whole flock, averaging 130 sheep. When first introduced, the llama usually is curious or neutral toward its new companions, while the sheep are either neutral or afraid. For the 201 introductions reported, the initial adjustment period lasted only a few hours for half the llamas, and nearly 80 percent were adjusted within a week. Many producers reported that guard llamas show intense interest and attachment to young lambs.
Did sheep losses decline?
Nearly three-fourths of the 145 sheep producers interviewed report that their worst predator is the coyote. Dogs are the leading predator in the remaining ranches, with only a few cases of mountain lions and bears. Before producers obtained their guard llamas, they had been losing an average of 26 sheep per year to predation, or about 11 percent of their flocks. After obtaining their llamas, the producers' losses dropped significantly to an average of 8 head per year, or about 1 percent; more than half of the producers had their losses reduced to zero. In their judgement, 80 percent of the producers rate their guard llama's ability to reduce predation losses of their sheep as "very effective" or "effective." All producers, however, reported continuing to use other preventive and control methods in addition to the llamas.
How and why do llamas protect sheep?
The highly social South American camelids are aggressive towards members of the canid family (coyotes, foxes, dogs etc.). Apparently, over time, canids have been important predators on the camelids, so that today, llamas are naturally wary of members of the dog family. In field studies in South America, guanacos and vicuñas often have been observed aggressively pursuing Andean and Patagonia foxes, but fleeing from mountain lions. Adult male guanacos are highly territorial, protecting their real estate and sounding alarms to their family group when predators are sighted.
Although not fully understood, once a guard llama becomes familiar with an area and is attached to the sheep, the pasture becomes the llama's territory and the flock becomes the llama's family group. Even for the gelded llama, these innate behaviors remain. Guard llamas are not passive bystanders, but are active leaders and protectors of their flocks. During daily movements of a flock, llamas may take the front position to lead the sheep, walk and graze in their midst, or trail at their heels.
It is not uncommon for the llama to separate from the flock and stand or rest on an adjacent hilltop or slope overlooking the sheep. While 70 percent of the producers interviewed said their llamas typically stay with their sheep, 25 percent reported that the llamas usually stay separate from the flock. Being separate is a behavior typical of wild, adult male guanacos, exhibited while overlooking both territory and family group for potential intruders and predators. About half of the people surveyed had seen their llamas interact with potential predators (coyote, dog, fox, or bear). Typical responses of a guard llama are alert attention (31 percent of the interactions, multiple responses possible), alarm call (32 percent), and walk to (25 percent) or run towards (62 percent) the predator, chase it (58 percent), kick or paw at it (21 percent), herd the sheep (34 percent), or position itself between the flock and predator (8 percent). In 3 percent of the cases it walked or ran away from the predator. Other times, ranchers reported their llamas killed a variety of intruders, including coyotes, woodchucks, and muskrats.
If the sheep ranch has a herding dog that typically chases, barks, and acts hostile towards the sheep during herding, the guard llama at first can be aggressive towards the dog. If there is a family dog on the premises that does not chase or bother the sheep, the llama usually will habituate to the dog and not attack it. However, some family dogs have been attacked and injured by guard llamas.
What works best?
The characteristics of llamas and sheep husbandry practices were correlated with the relative effectiveness of guard llamas in reducing predation after the llamas were introduced to the sheep. Although some intact males may attempt to mount ewes, there was no difference reported between geldings and intact males in their effectiveness in protecting sheep. There also was no reported difference between males and females, although the sample size of single female guard llamas was small. The high cost of females, usually several thousand dollars, makes them an impractical choice unless they also are used as breeding stock. It does make a difference whether single or multiple guard llamas are used. Multiple guard llamas work in some cases, but overall, predation in this study was higher in flocks with multiple llamas (7 percent of the flock) compared with flocks with one llama (1 percent loss).
Although llamas are introduced to sheep in a variety of ways, the situation made little difference in the llama's eventual effectiveness in protecting the sheep. Sheep first introduced to guard llamas on open range, however, experienced higher predation than those introduced into a corral. Although lambs affectionately interacting and playing with a llama is a striking and impressionable sight, llamas introduced to sheep with lambs ultimately are no more effective than llamas introduced to flocks without lambs. Llama and sheep behavior toward each other does not influence the llama's guarding abilities. While there were no apparent differences in losses of sheep grazing with a guard llama in open rangeland versus rangeland with cover (forested, shrubby, gullies, etc.), this remains a question for study. We would expect a llama to be able to more easily detect a potential predator in open terrain. There may be, however, other complicating factors of which we are currently unaware. From this study, researchers were unable to determine the ideal age to first introduce a guard llama to sheep. Actual age of the guard llama (excluding those less than 1 year old) is not related to its effectiveness. However, it appears that llamas do not reach their full protective potential until 1 to 2 years old. Similarly, the llama's wild counterpart, the guanaco, doesn't become territorial until 2 to 4 years of age.
Care and management of llamas
Llamas are easy to keep. More than 80 percent of the producers interviewed said the daily care for their guard llamas is the same as for their sheep, and no special feeds are given. Average annual expense for feed (not including pasture) is $90 and miscellaneous veterinary costs are approximately $16.
Llama breeders traditionally wean offspring at 6 to 8 months of age and castrate males at 6 to 24 months of age. A 250-pound gelded llama typically consumes 7 to 10 pounds of good grass hay per day. Granular or block mineral supplement and access to fresh water should be available free choice, and grain is not necessary. Llamas typically don't bloat, even with a sudden change of pasture or hay. Illness in a llama can best be detected by making daily visual checks for subtle changes in behavior. If a llama is sick and won't get up, colic or heat stress should be suspected. Depending upon the area and the internal parasite load, llamas need to be dewormed 2 to 4 times a year. Annual vaccinations for Clostridial diseases, including tetanus, are recommended. Contact a llama association for information on llama care and management, and consult a veterinarian for specific health problems.
Cautions and problems
While 75 percent of the 145 ranchers interviewed reported that their llamas did not negatively affect their sheep, and 90 percent reported that the sheep did not negatively affect the llama, there are some potential problems. Aggressiveness and breeding are the most commonly reported problems among the 25 percent of respondents that said "yes". No problems were reported for the 10 female llamas in this study. Twenty-five percent of 61 intact males and 5 percent of 135 gelded llamas attempted to breed ewes. Some producers lost sheep due to this breeding behavior. In one instance, a single male killed 100 ewes before the problem was determined. If an intact, sexually mature male is used, he should be closely watched during the breeding season. Castration can modify this behavior, but not necessarily in all cases.
Five percent of the producers report their guard llamas are overprotective, so much so that the producer sometimes has difficulty working with the sheep. A producer's ability to separate the llama from the flock, in a catch pen, for example, can help overcome this problem.
Nine out of 10 of the sheep ranchers said that their sheep do not negatively affect the llama. When problems arise, it is often because the sheep are crowding the llama away from food. To overcome this problem, food for the llama should be put in a feeder high enough to be out of reach of the sheep.
Owner satisfaction, costs and savings
Nearly 80 percent of the sheep producers reported that they are either "very satisfied" or "satisfied" with their guard llamas. Predator control and easy maintenance are cited as the top benefits. Two-thirds of the producers report no disadvantages about their guard llamas, and 85 percent indicate they would recommend guard llamas to others.
An average annual savings of $1,034 was reported by 86 producers who had owned a llama for three years. Llamas commonly live for 10 to 15 years. When the initial investment ($300-800) and annual expenses ($105) are factored out, the long-term savings of a guard llama could be substantial. Fiftyeight producers could not estimate savings or losses by having a guard llama, while one purebred producer saves an average of $20,000 per year.
Guard llamas vs. guard dogs
How does this new information on guard llamas compare with previous findings about guard dogs? The majority of guard dogs originated in eastern Europe and show a mixture of juvenile, maternal, and protective behaviors towards sheep, compared with the predator-like stalking and chasing behaviors of herding dogs that originated in the British Isles.
While guard dogs have been shown to be effective in reducing coyote predation on sheep, as with llamas, there have been problems. A significant concern is the short life span and premature death of guard dogs due to accidents, culling, and disease: 50 percent die before 3 years of age.
Beginning as small pups, guard dogs must be raised exclusively with sheep and with minimal human contact. Many are not as effective during their first year of life. Over-attachment to people and aggressiveness towards sheep also have been observed. Another disadvantage is that dogs must be fed daily.
Not a panacea
These results indicate that guard llamas offer a viable non-lethal alternative to the problem of coyote predation on sheep. However, no matter what the approach when dealing with the adaptive coyote, the concept of "protection against" coyote predation is an overstatement. A more realistic expectation is a reduction of coyote predation.
While the results of this research are encouraging, the guard llama should not be seen as a cure-all. Some ranchers continue to have problems with predation, but the average rancher experiences a substantial reduction in losses with the use of a guard llama.
However, don't count out the opportunistic coyote. This predator is well-known for adapting to new situations. It hunts alone, in pairs, and in small groups. How guard llamas respond to group-hunting coyotes or to high densities of coyotes is not known. One rancher reported that a 7-month-old llama was killed by a group of coyotes. Guard llamas can be an effective part of a rancher’s overall predator prevention and control program. As stated earlier, no single approach used alone should be relied upon. It must be integrated with other preventive and control options.
Guard llamas may have application to other species. This study found that a number of ranches and farms successfully use llamas to protect ducks, geese, goats, deer, and even cattle. Such expanded use of guard llamas is intriguing and deserves further assessment. While this study has answered some questions, many remain to be addressed.
Coyote predation is a serious problem for the sheep industry. The traditional approach to controlling predator losses has been to trap and shoot coyotes. During this study, 145 sheep producers using guard llamas were interviewed to determine characteristics of the guard llamas and husbandry practices. Some of the results include:
We would like to thank the sheep producers who patiently answered our many interview questions about their experiences with guard llamas. Without their insight this study would not have been possible. Thanks to Iowa State University, International Llama Association, and Rocky Mountain Llama and Alpaca Association for their financial support. Special appreciation goes to Terry Price for his encouragement and support, and to Jim Forseth and Glen Frame who generously shared their knowledge of guard llamas and provided us with numerous names of guard llama owners in their area. Reviewed by Curtis R. Youngs, assistant professor, ISU Department of Animal Science; James Pease, ISU Extension wildlife specialist; Daniel G. Morrical, ISU Extension sheep specialist; and Jim Luchsinger, wildlife biologist, U. S. Department of Agriculture Animal Plant Health Inspection Service (APHIS).